Caution - Russian Wikipedia: a story with socionics, or watchmen against academicians

Authors

  • A.V. Bukalov
  • E.A. Donchenko
  • A.M. Eljashevich
  • V.V. Gritsak-Groener
  • et al

Keywords:

socionics, Wikipedia, subjectivism, arbitrariness, personality types, science, authoritative sources

Abstract

In a collective article by scientists from a number of countries, the principles of editing the “People´s Encyclopedia Wikipedia” are considered. It is shown that fatal defects are inherent in its functioning, since articles are written not by specialists, but by amateurs who, as a rule, do not have the proper qualifications. As an example, the situation with the “Socionics” article in the Russian Wikipedia (unlike the vast majority of versions in other languages) is considered, which not only contains false and erroneous statements, but even the fundamental principles and rules of Wikipedia itself are completely violated. For example, dozens of authoritative sources that define socionics as a long-established academic science or scientific direction are completely ignored and discarded. Sections on the numerous long-term application of socionic methods in practice are systematically discarded: in manned cosmonautics, civil aviation, management, pedagogy, psychotherapy, sports, linguistics, didactics, family counseling, etc. At the same time, a group of Russian Wikipedia participants who seized control over editing article, and being clearly incompetent in this matter, shows open aggression towards any attempts to correct the situation, indefinitely blocking all those who disagree with such actions, and also spreading its vandalism attempts to the English version of Wikipedia.

References

Википедия: «Академик против вахтера». — URL: https://ru.wikipedia.org//wiki/Википедия:Академик_ против_вахтёра

Крысько В. Словарь-справочник по социальной психологии. - СПб.: Питер, 2003. - С. 310. - ISBN 5-314-00021-0.

Жуков С. Стать космонавтом! - М., 2011.

Букалов А.В., Карпенко О.Б. Соционика как академическая научная дисциплина. // Соционика, мен-тология и психология личности. — 2013. — №№ 1–2. — URL: https://socionic.info/pdf/soc-academ.pdf.

Шкавро З.Н. Использование методов соционики в диссертационных работах, защищенных в области различных дисциплин // Соционика, ментология и психология личности. — 2013. — № 5. — С. 19–36. — URL: https://publishing.socionic.info/socionics/article/view/342.

Самойлова И.Г. Интегральный тип информационного метаболизма малой группы в производствен-ной организации. — Диссертация, Ярославский университет, научный рук. д.п.н. Новиков В. В., 1996.

Букалов А.В., Карпенко О.Б. Соционика и психоинформационные технологии в образовательном процессе // Материалы международной научной конференции XVII ЦАРСКОСЕЛЬСКИЕ ЧТЕНИЯ. — СПб: Изд-во Ленинград. гос. ун-т, 2013.

Fink G. and Mayrhofer W . Cross-cultural competence and management - setting the stage // European J. Cross-Cultural Competence and Management. - 2009. - Vol. 1. - No. 1.

Бегун В.В., Широков С.В., Бегун С.В., Письменный Е.Н., Литвинов В.В., Казачков И.В. Культура безопасности в ядерной энергетике: учебник для студ. техн. вузов. — Киев, 2012. – 563 с. — ISBN: 978-966-2726-12-1.

Horwood J., Maw A. Theatre Teams Assembled Using Personality Profiles Can Improve Predicted Teamworking Scores // Bulletin of The Royal College of Surgeons of England. - 2012. - Vol. 94. - No 3. - Pp. 1-6.

Литвинов Б.В. Основы инженерной деятельности: Курс лекций. - Екатеринбург: УГТУ-УПИ, 2000. - 224 с. - ISBN 5-230-06549-6.

Соционика https://traditio.wiki/%D0%A1%D0%BE%D1%86%D0%B8%D0%BE%D0%BD%D0%B8%D0%BA%D0%B0

Published

2022-07-29

How to Cite

Bukalov, A., Donchenko, E., Eljashevich, A., Gritsak-Groener, V., & et al и. . (2022). Caution - Russian Wikipedia: a story with socionics, or watchmen against academicians. Psychology and Socionics of Interpersonal Relationships, (1-2), 42–51. Retrieved from https://publishing.socionic.info/index.php/psychology/article/view/2822

Issue

Section

Articles